Carol Scott
Carol Scott
Knoxville, TN
Sous Chef
Kitchen Experience
4 years
Culinary Education
Le Cordon Bleu of Las Vegas
Culinary Inspiration

Carol Scott was a contestant on Season 5 of Hell's Kitchen. She ranked in 7th place.

Personality Edit

Carol was known for her near 24/7 smile, and for being mean-spirited, which lead to a massive feud with Andrea due to her hatred for her attitude. She also blamed others for mistakes and attempted to sabotage Andrea out of spite.

Season 5Edit

Episode 1Edit

Before dinner service, the women revealed their team name: Team Saffron. It was eventually changed to "Spice Racks" after a request from Colleen. Carol was assigned as a waitress.

During dinner service, a power outage happened, but that did not stop Carol to give an outstanding service by serving wine to her customers. She was responsible for the red team's victory by being rated 90% above average as a waitress by the customers.

Episode 2Edit

During the Scallops Challenge, Carol gave one of the red team's best individual performance by scoring 8 points. But, it fell out short as her team lost 35-36.

Her team lost the dinner service, and Carol gave an emotional standing ovation during Ji's departure, along with her teammates and the blue team.

Episode 3Edit

The red team lost the Meat & Cow Challenge.

Her team won the Steakhouse dinner service.

Episode 4Edit

Both teams lost the dinner service, and were asked to nominate two members each.

She was not nominated for elimination.

Episode 5Edit

Both teams lost the dinner service, and for the red team, LA was named "Best of the Worst".

She was not nominated for elimination.

Episode 6Edit

Inthe Bar Mitzvah tasting challenge, she was responsible for creating the burger. She made a stuffed cheeseburger, and despite the red teams warning, she decided to use blue cheese for it. Her team ended up losing the challenge as Max (the birthday boy) found the blue cheese too strong for him. The red team was punished by setting up the dinning room for tomorrow night with a basketball court and dance floor.

The red team lost the Bar Mitzvah dinner service, and Andrea was named "Best of the Worst".

She was not nominated for elimination.

Episode 7Edit

During dinner service, Carol was on the appetizer station. After serving a risotto where the rice was overcooked by J, she served an undercooked pasta dish. She blamed Andrea for her mistake, and both of them had to eat it in the dining room in front of the customers. Her team won the dinner service.

Episode 8Edit

During the Blind Taste Test, Carol gave one of the best individual performances by scoring 3 points of a possible 4. The red team won the challenge 8-7.

Carol was at the meat station this service. One of her lamb dishes was sent back for being undercooked, and she struggled to pull herself back together. Eventually her problems, along with Andrea'sand LA's resulted in Ramsay closing down the red kitchen after the blue team completed service. Her team lost the dinner service, and nobody was safe.

She was the red team's second nominee for elimination, with LA being the first. After Andrea joined them, she survived elimination.

Episode 9Edit

Before dinner service, both teams were asked to create their own menus. Carol came up with a potato dauphinoise dish. During service, Carol undercooked her own dish many times, leading her to give up. After an undercooked steak by her returned to the kitchen, Ramsay shut down both kitchens, and declared the red team winners after a 54% satisfaction rate by the customers, compared to the blue team's 36%.

Despite the fact that she won the dinner service, Carol was eliminated for sabotaging her team and giving up after the dauphinoise fiasco. This marked the first time in the show's history that a contestant from the winning team is eliminated.

Ramsay's comment: "Carol knew she was out of her depth in Hell's Kitchen. I just put her out of her misery."

Episode 14/15Edit

When she came back for the last dinner service of the season, Carol was Danny's last pick, following Ben and Giovanni. She later said she wanted to be on Paula's team as she believed in woman power. Danny won the finals over Paula.

Trivia Edit

  • She is the first contestant ever to be eliminated despite being on the winning team.
  • Her and Andrea were responsible for one of the greatest rivalries of Hell's Kitchen.


  • "I'm getting yelled at because this stupid bitch (Andrea) can't fucking cook?!"
  • "Oh I wanted to punch you in the neck!"

Ad blocker interference detected!

Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.